User blog:Applegirl/Youtube wikia suggestions ?

This blog is an open discussion about what you as wikia contributor think about the current state of the wikia. My personal opinion is that we shouldn't have separate pages for characters people use on their channels. I'm also against the making of separate pages and writing in transcripts for what a youtuber did or said in a certain video. To me, that is really stretching the borders of this wikia and creating a separate video page for each video the youtuber uploaded (which I see some people are doing). I would have no problem with someone creating a page for a video that has gotten a merit, like, most viewed video on youtube or something. Anyone is free to disagree with me, but of course I want to hear the reasons for it.

Let me know what you think about:


 * Having pages for youtubers who have a small subscriber count. Should we only limit pages to be made to youtubers who have a higher amount of subscribers, or only youtubers who are more well known, or have been on youtube longer?


 * What detonates a Wikiatubia page. Should it only be information pages on youtubers, their channels, the most popular or well known videos on youtube and so on? What would be an unacceptable page to make?